Checking vs. Savings Bonuses: Which Online Bank Pays More

The Truth I Learned About Bank Bonuses That Nobody Tells You

When I first started experimenting with online bank bonuses, I honestly didn’t know what I was doing. I saw people online talking about signup bonuses, cash rewards, high APY, and free money, but I didn’t understand which bonuses were actually worth it.

Should I focus on checking account bonuses?
Are savings bonuses better?
Are online banks really paying people hundreds of dollars just to sign up?

The more I dug into it — and the more banks I personally tested — the more I realized something important:

Checking and savings bonuses are completely different worlds, and one of them consistently pays more.

In this guide, I’m breaking everything down in a clear, human way so you can understand exactly:

• How checking bonuses work
• How savings bonuses work
• Which one pays more (based on real experience)
• Which bonus is easier to qualify for
• What type of account beginners should start with
• What online banks are worth your time
• What mistakes to avoid

And I’ll also share the online bank I personally use and recommend, because it checks all the boxes and offers simple, real cash rewards.

Before we dive deep, if you want a bonus that’s easy to qualify for:

➡️ SIGN UP FOR VARO HERE

Now let’s begin.

---

Part 1: Understanding Checking Bonuses

What Exactly Is a Checking Bonus?

A checking bonus is cash a bank gives you for opening a checking account and completing a requirement. It’s usually one of the simplest bonuses you can get because checking accounts are made for daily use.

Checking bonuses typically require:

• A direct deposit
• A small qualifying deposit
• A few debit card transactions
• Keeping the account open for a certain amount of time

These bonuses usually come with no fees, especially if it’s an online bank.

Why Banks Offer Checking Bonuses

Checking accounts are “primary accounts,” meaning:

• Your paycheck goes there
• Your bills get paid there
• Your debit card is linked to it
• You use it daily

Banks LOVE having your checking account because it means you’ll use the account long-term.

So they reward you upfront to attract you.

How Much Do Checking Bonuses Typically Pay?

Here’s the truth from what I’ve seen:

Checking bonuses pay more than savings bonuses in most cases.

Typical checking bonuses:

• $25
• $50
• $75
• $100
• $150
• $200+

High-end promotions even reach $300–$400, but those usually require high deposits or strict conditions (I avoid those).

The best bonuses come from no-fee online banks that keep requirements simple.

---

Part 2: Understanding Savings Bonuses

What Is a Savings Bonus?

A savings bonus is cash a bank gives you for:

• Maintaining a minimum savings balance
• Reaching a certain balance target
• Automatically transferring money monthly
• Opening a high-yield savings account

Savings bonuses are usually harder to get because banks want you to deposit and hold money.

Why Banks Offer Savings Bonuses

Savings accounts help banks because:

• They get access to your stored money
• They use those deposits to fund loans
• They depend on long-term balances

Because savings accounts financially benefit banks differently than checking accounts, banks reward you in a different way.

How Much Do Savings Bonuses Typically Pay?

Savings bonuses are often smaller than checking bonuses unless they require high deposits.

Typical savings bonuses:

• $10
• $20
• $40
• $50–$75 (rare but possible)

But here’s the problem:

Savings bonuses almost ALWAYS require you to deposit and hold money, sometimes up to:

• $300
• $500
• $1,000
• $5,000+

And you have to keep the money there for 30–90 days.

For many people, that’s too much commitment.

This is why I personally choose checking bonuses first and then look for online banks with high APY savings instead of bonuses.

High APY pays much more long-term.

---

Part 3: Which Bonus Pays More (Checking vs Savings)?

This is the big question — and here’s the honest truth based on years of reviewing banks:

Checking bonuses pay more.

And they are easier to qualify for.
And they are faster.
And they require less money.

Savings bonuses rarely beat them unless you deposit thousands of dollars.

Why Checking Bonuses Pay More

1. Banks want your daily activity
2. Direct deposit users stay long-term
3. Banks compete aggressively in the checking space
4. Checking accounts tie you into the bank’s ecosystem

Savings bonuses simply can’t compete unless you’re willing to lock in large amounts of money.

Real Example Breakdown

Let’s compare real-world numbers:

Checking bonus example:

Deposit: Direct deposit of your paycheck
Reward: $50
Hold time: None
Difficulty: Easy

Savings bonus example:

Deposit: $1,000
Hold time: 60 days
Reward: $20
Difficulty: Moderate

See the huge difference?

That’s why 90% of people prefer checking bonuses when starting out.

And that’s why I personally recommend banks like Varo — because they offer checking bonuses with simple requirements.

One of the easiest bonuses you can get right now:

➡️ SIGN UP FOR VARO HERE

---

Part 4: How I Choose Between Checking and Savings Bonuses

I always use this exact thought process:

1. How much do I have available to deposit?

If I don’t want to lock money, I choose checking.

2. Do I want fast payouts?

Checking bonuses are faster.

3. Do I want long-term value?

Checking bonuses paired with a high-yield savings account are the best combo.

4. Is it beginner-friendly?

Checking bonuses win every time.

5. Does the bank have fees?

I only use no-fee online banks.

6. Is the bank easy to use?

I look for:

• A clean mobile app
• Fast notifications
• Instant transfers
• FDIC insurance

7. Does it offer both bonuses AND long-term perks?

This is where Varo stands out, and why I recommend it so often.

Varo offers:

• No fees
• Cash rewards
• Easy bonus requirements
• Cashback options
• High APY savings
• Early direct deposit
• A clean modern app

It checks every box.

---

Part 5: The Long-Term Value: APY Matters More Than Savings Bonuses

Savings bonuses are usually small, but high APY savings accounts pay much more over time — and require no “bonus conditions.”

Here’s an example:

Let’s say a savings bonus pays $20 if you deposit $1,000.

But a high APY (like the one Varo offers) can earn:

• $35–$50 per year
• Without “holding periods”
• Without meeting requirements
• Without locking money

High APY savings accounts outperform most savings bonuses.

That’s why I personally choose:

• Checking bonuses to get free cash
• High APY savings accounts to grow money long-term

That combination gives you the best of both worlds.

Part 6: The Real Question — What Should You Choose?

Based on my experience reviewing dozens of banks, here’s who benefits most from each bonus type:

---

Checking Bonuses Are Best For:

• Beginners
• People who want fast rewards
• People who don’t want to deposit high amounts
• People who want no fees
• People building emergency funds
• Students
• Freelancers
• Anyone who wants simple requirements

Savings Bonuses Are Best For:

• People with $1,000–$5,000 they won’t touch
• People who like meeting goals
• People who want extra rewards on top of APY

But realistically, the average person benefits MUCH more from checking bonuses.

This is why banks like Varo are so popular — they give you both:

• Easy checking bonuses
• A high APY savings account

To open an account that offers both:

➡️ SIGN UP FOR VARO HERE

---

Part 7: The Mistakes I Made (So You Don’t Make Them)

After years of testing banks, I made many mistakes before learning what works.

Here are the biggest ones:

1. I chased BIG bonuses with complicated rules

Some bonuses look huge, but the requirements feel like a job.

2. I locked money in savings bonuses I didn’t need

Holding $1,000+ for months was unnecessary.

3. I ignored APY

I focused too much on bonuses and not long-term growth.

4. I used banks with bad mobile apps

Smooth tech matters more than people think.

5. I didn’t track payout timelines

Some banks take 90 days. I now choose faster payouts.

Once I simplified my strategy, I earned more bonuses with less stress.

---

Part 8: The Bank I Recommend for Checking OR Savings Bonuses

After reviewing many online banks, Varo remains my top pick, especially for people who want:

• Real bonuses
• No fees
• Cash rewards
• Early paycheck access
• High APY
• A strong mobile experience
• FDIC insurance

It’s beginner-friendly, flexible, and gives you both checking AND savings perks.

Ready to earn your first online bank bonus?

➡️ SIGN UP FOR VARO HERE

---

Final Thoughts: Which Bonus Pays More Overall?

Let me give you the honest answer, based on years of personal experience:

Checking bonuses pay more, pay faster, and require less work.

Savings bonuses pay less, require higher deposits, and take longer.

If your goal is:

• Free cash
• Fast rewards
• Easy requirements
• A better bank
• No fees
• Long-term growth

Then checking bonuses are the best place to start — especially with online banks like Varo that offer strong savings options, cashback rewards, and a smooth banking experience.

If you want a bank that pays new customers AND makes everyday banking easy:

➡️ SIGN UP FOR VARO HERE